Pages

Saturday, April 4, 2015

For M 4/6 (comment required)

A quick summary of our start-of-class discussion on Friday:

Improvisation manifests itself in many ways in many musical cultures. In Western Euro-American culture, improvisation was a central element of what we now call "classical" music for centuries, diminishing in the second half of the nineteenth century and the twentieth century to the point that by the post-WW II era it was nearly forgotten by classical musicians, except for organists and those new-music specialists who played avant-garde music that was not fully notated. 

Improvisation was and is at the heart of jazz, and improvisation exists to varying degrees in rock, pop, and folk music. But look back, and you'll discover that especially in the music we now call "Baroque" (1600-1750), improvisation was at least equally valued as were compositions in performances.

Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, Liszt we remember today for their compositions, but in their time they were renowned for their improvisational abilities. In the Baroque era, much music was not fully notated. Keyboard parts in vocal and instrumental ensemble music were rarely written out; keyboard players would have only a bass line and chord symbols and were expected to be able to fill out the parts, just as musicians in jazz, pop, and rock are expected to be able to play from chord charts today. 

Today, people improvise music for a variety of purposes:
  • As a performance art (i.e., playing or singing music that is completely or partly improvised for an audience, in a setting that makes a distinction between performers and audience members).
  • As a way of self-expression, interpersonal connection, and personal and group growth and development. We have experienced this with our self-led drum circles that use improvised rhythms and are exploring this with pitched instruments and voices.
  • As a way of exploring and learning: improvising to work on keeping a pulse, on being aware of others making music with you, or to experiment with a musical idea or structure (such as an interval, dynamics, a particular technique, etc.).
These purposes can and do coexist, of course. Quite obviously, we can express ourselves and connect with others when performing! And we are constantly learning. 

This weekend, let's reflect on and discuss in the comments below your experience with improvisation so far, whether in class or elsewhere, especially how you have (or haven't) used improvising in performance, as a way of expressing yourself and connecting with others, and as a way of learning. (Have you every done exercises in theory or musicianship classes that had an improvised element?)

Just as importantly, how do you want to grow as a person and musician as we have our last two sessions together (both of which will focus largely on improvisation activities, in addition to more discussion of the New Yorker article).  

The writing prompt:
  1. Describe improvisation experiences you have had in class or elsewhere using the this idea that there are three main focuses: performing for an audience, self-expression/connection/growth, and learning through experimentation.
  2. Discuss how you want to grow as we have our final sessions.  
I strongly encourage you to do some improvisation on your own or with others between now and Monday's class!

17 comments:

  1. I haven't had any musical improve experience but in high school I was a part of my school's poetry club and we did a lot of improve poetry. We would be given a topic in advance and would be able to write a few points, and then in front of everyone we would come up with a poem on the spot; kind of like a poetry jam session. It was a lot of fun and helped with enabling creative flow. In class these last two time I have channeled the same creativity I brought to poetry.

    I'm not sure what I want to get out of the the last two class sessions, but I'm not sure if I've been connecting with other around me. I've been very concerned with what I play myself that I haven't really been listening to others. I want to make more connections.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have improvised complete songs where I sing and a friend plays guitar or piano, and I always surprise myself with how well the songs turn out when I have no clue at the beginning where the song is going to go (once I improvised a song about sriracha sauce!). These usually happen in casual settings where I am very comfortable, and in the last two classes I want to develop my improvisation comfort on piano towards the comfort I have on voice. I want to listen better to the musicians improv-ing with me (it's a little harder because it's not just one instrument or voice anymore) as well.

    ReplyDelete
  3. One of my most meaningful improvisation moments have always been when I perform with Irish bands back home in Detroit. It's tradition to never really play with sheet music. Most tunes and reels are memorized and have been passed down through generations. Most Irish musicians improv based on their ability to hear the music and adapt as they play. The same goes for singing Irish tunes. The different inflections and turns that are native to Irish music are all improvised and differ from Singer to Singer. I have always enjoyed singing with Irish bands and it is something that makes me really happy. I hope that in these last few sessions we as a group approach improv with the attitude that it may not be perfect but when it is it really is something incredible.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have done a little bit of improvisation before through a High School school program called Rendezvous. My school did it every year and students could audition with a song of their choice with chords for the band and then if you made it in you could rehearse with the band and then perform it for audiences. It was a big deal for my school and city. I sang Summertime in the style of Ella Fitz. my senior year and since I was able to do some improvisation while I sang that song with the big band playing behind me. It was fun to just feel and hear this wave of sound coming behind me with so much sound and then I was able to do what I wanted. It was wonderful! I don't have many opportunities to do improvisation but I actually really like it a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My improvisation experiences happen usually when I need an outlet for my emotions. I usually keep to myself if I'm having a bad day or am going through some nasty stuff, and being able to have an outlet for all the bad is very nice. Picking up my violin and just letting all my troubles go without worrying about what I'm playing is an incredible way to release. Sometimes it's tonal and sometimes it really really isn't, I don't worry about that though. The key to it for me is not worrying about anything at all, because fear of making a mistake really gets in the way of the creative process.

    I hope to learn how to channel my unstructured thoughts into comprehensible musical thoughts, into something other people can understand just as well as I do.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My improvisation experiences happen usually when I need an outlet for my emotions. I usually keep to myself if I'm having a bad day or am going through some nasty stuff, and being able to have an outlet for all the bad is very nice. Picking up my violin and just letting all my troubles go without worrying about what I'm playing is an incredible way to release. Sometimes it's tonal and sometimes it really really isn't, I don't worry about that though. The key to it for me is not worrying about anything at all, because fear of making a mistake really gets in the way of the creative process.

    I hope to learn how to channel my unstructured thoughts into comprehensible musical thoughts, into something other people can understand just as well as I do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I didn't ever really feel like I had the freedom to improvise until I took a songwriting class over winter term. I feel like it really helped me open up, and bring my creativity to a different level. I found my songs turned out better when I just started doing them. I would record myself and then pick out parts that I liked and would piece them together to build songs that I could actually present in class.

    I hope to expose myself to more opportunities for improvisation in my time at DePauw. I think it is not only an incredible performance tool, but also a really great way to let out emotions, and bring music to a specific moment or place even if you don't want to play or sing something thats written on the page. I think finding new ways of expression is such an important thing to do and strive for.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have had more experiencing improvising with dance. This is very different that anything I do on my own instrument, and really does require an idea of what you're supposed to be feeling before you start. I have not yet improved in front of an audience in this way, but doing it in front of the mirror really helped me figure out the way my body wants to move naturally.
    I've only improved on my instrument in this class, and for Randy in my lessons. When he asked me to do this I was actually very nervous - as if I could play something wrong when I'm improving. After a few times of doing this, I realized that there were no wrong notes, and that made me much more comfortable with my instrument.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I have had most of my improv experience with acting. But like I mentioned in class Friday, I have had some exposure to different types of violin improv through Suzuki. Personally, I enjoy improving alone. Its definitely because I'm not great at it and I prefer to practice and find enjoyment myself first, because that way I feel I can share it with others more successfully. If I improv, it is usually centered on Jazz. I will usually pick a Jazz violin piece and pick out the melody and then try to improv on the improvised sections. This fits my comfort level because its the perfect mix of structure and freedom. I don't know what I expect from our last improv sections together. I guess maybe to feel more comfortable improvising in a group setting is a big one. Also to learn some new techniques that I can apply to my personal Jazz improv.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Improv has never been my strong point because I always feel like whatever I do will be wrong or awkward. The game I played with vocalists in my acting class where we improv "made music" really helped me because I felt like I was such a strong part of the group. I want my comfort level to go up with this group as much as it was for the last time I improv'd consistently so I will feel the same and that whatever I decided to contribute will make me feel like part of a whole.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Improv has a lot of things to offer that I wasn't expecting! Most importantly was the ensemble experience and how opportunities to create music within the context of the group are so special, and unique. Especially in comparison to meticulously working on a solo piece and performing (which obviously has it's own merits), there is sometimes, arguably more opportunity to practice music in it's most practical and enjoyable function-with others. Group experiences and improv also help us realize the importance of committing to the choice you make in improv. There is no reason to half ass something, if you find something that potentially works, go with it. The rest of the group will adhere to most things you commit to it, and interweave it into the music we're making. Improv has without a doubt reinforced previous ideas associated with collaborative music making, and I'm thankful for the experience!

    ReplyDelete
  14. In music, I rarely improv around other people. Usually, it's in the middle of a practice session when I'm having trouble separating myself from some thought or feeling. When this happens, I usually improvise while I think through whatever is bothering me.
    I've had more experience improvising in front of people while acting. I always thought this was fun, although I disliked how nervous and anxious it made me, which is why I avoided it. I think the same thing happened with music, which is why I rarely improvise in front of anyone else.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Like I mentioned in class, I did a vocal jazz camp a few years ago, and I was the only person with no jazz background whatsoever. We did a TON of scatting during the camp, which was the most terrifying part for me. I'll be honest, scatting is not my favorite. I like to be in control too much! But I'll admit, over the course of the week I did get better at it and slowly became more comfortable. If the camp was longer, say three weeks or so, and we continued to scat every day I probably would've felt extremely comfortable by the end, and maybe would've even started to believe I was good at scatting! At the end of the week we had a performance and included in that performance was scatting. We all got up on stage, got in a line, and each scatted a few measures. I was TERRIFIED. But, I got through it, and I must say I'm sure I'm a better musician because of it.
    As far as my goal for the remaining class time goes, I'd just like to get over my fear of musical improvisation. I think my biggest downfall when it comes to improv is my head getting in the way of itself. Once I get rid of that fear, I think I'll be much better at improv and be more open to doing it more often.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I mean getting up in front of other people is really hard even when you have a prepared piece so I think I took away from this class the most is being yourself and just letting it happen.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Self-expression/connection/growth, and learning through experimentation were the two focuses that I really improved upon and came to understand! I personally never experienced a thoughtful performance in which I can apply what I learned to, but I gained so much more outside the actual performance setting. In jazz I am currently in need of technical work, not necessarily the creative process of it. SO, will be applying what I learned to my personal philosophy on life, the way I respond and connect with others(and nature), and learning new things through the trials and errors that I experience through improvisation! =)

    ReplyDelete